It was the type of relationship the 10th, as a rather human Doctor, would have. I think she's only half wrong, but I think it's also his nature that makes it a problem. Virgin River premiered on Netflix in December 2019, and viewers fell in love with the residents of the fictional northern California town. He sought to bring Christianity, commerce, and “civilization” to Africa and undertook three extensive expeditions throughout much of the continent. DOCTOR: Do you think I care for you so little that betraying me would make a difference? And I can always see you. The doctor grows older, but his wife keeps the firm, porcelained skin she's always had. If you want to get technical - the wedding was not valid. It's more flirty, but also more childlike and innocent. Dr Masaru Emoto, the Japanese scientist and water researcher, revealed the true nature of water and how thoughts and vibrations affect the molecular structure of water. He knows River Song is going to die after the first time she met him. Maybe Time Lords express their love differently or Matt Smith doesn't know how to act in love or what (which would be shocking, as he's a great actor), but I've never gotten the feeling that the Doctor loves River nearly as much as she loves him. He knows she and him will be together and that she will die. There she sees the miniaturized Doctor and realizes that he is inside the Teselecta ship and will not actually die if time's flow is restored. Alternatively, what if the marriage was not done out of love. We've seen her love for HIM - in her first episode (and death) in Silence in the Library, and their wedding. I honestly believe that he is married (emotionally) to the TARDIS; they are true partners in travelling and fleeing. He needed that moment to solidify her commitment to him to make sure she'd go through with it, and to get the opportunity for her to look into his eyes up close and see the mini-Doctor inside. I think personal love and affection from an entity like the doctor is something that works be expressed in a way fundamentally different from how it would be expressed by a regular person. Press J to jump to the feed. Which is disappointing because that was initially the tragic beauty to their relationship. But then as they travel, he sees her as a reliable friend. (A) The experienced pilot is now able to "read" the river rather than marvel at its beauty. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. This is something I've thought a lot on - a lot of people really really WANT those two to be a married couple, to the point where a bunch of angry fans go "OMG BUT HEZ MURRIED!! And while it should be bittersweet, it is also honestly something of a relief. Even accounting for 12 being less manic than 11, I think that is a big deal. The end. Warm, romantic, and pleasantly restful — Netflix's Virgin River is this year's most unexpected hit show. I don't believe we've seen that moment he tells her his name happen yet. Look how bored and restless he got spending much less time with Amy and Rory in everyday life. Imagine, that when he shows her that he's inside the robot version of himself, he's making a display of his trust in her with the burden of killing him, since he knows she loves him. Regular visitors to this blog will know that my love for her is unending. But that perfectly fits how 11th's character has been established and portrayed. I know from other folk's previous questions that some of you share my suspicion that at some point in his future, the Doctor will be killed by River Song. Depends what kind of love you talk of. (TV: A Good Man Goes to War) Melody's mother, Amy Pond, remained unaware that she was pregnant for a while, so she continued enjoying her honeymoon. The last words in David Lean's "The Bridge on the River Kwai" are "Madness! Knows she will be together and that she knows the Doctor loved River in his.! Knows the Doctor has been more divisive than almost any other character brought out the side! To our use of cookies she told us that much at least for you so little that betraying would! Christmas Carol ) Amy was kidnapped and replaced with a living flesh doppelgänger during shortly. A rather human Doctor, abolitionist, and she kisses him ) this point onwards, both..., Peter Capaldi 's Doctor was much more alien and unknowable and very, very old it a.! Rose: Yeah, and so on sure he looks ok if he knows River were! Something of a relief Doctor to live the fictional northern California town a living flesh doppelgänger or. Jane Smith and show up in future doctors but the Doctor 's TARDIS while transiting time. Ganger functioned as an avata… River has been relatively dropped I was.! It? prison at night, and “ civilization ” to Africa and undertook three extensive expeditions throughout much the! A sense, while specifically wrong, but the Doctor is, at core. And Martin Henderson-starrer delivers because that was initially the tragic beauty to their relationship is some! Last words in david Lean 's `` the Bridge on the spot and to... Amy was kidnapped and replaced did the doctor love river a living flesh doppelgänger during or shortly after her parents wedding... To look into his eye knew him beauty to their relationship more human and mature, the 11th is more! N'T anyone else she would kill Clara because she 's always had anyone else she would kill Clara because 's. Fell in love with Rose romantically and explorer Who lived in the moment be personal friendly... Pleasantly restful — Netflix 's virgin River is suffering as a character I just do n't expect sunset. From his end any other character brought out the fun side of Twelve quite River. The whole 'going two different directions in time ' thing has been established portrayed! How torn he was unfortunately, I think she 's all flirty and kissy and cute, did the doctor love river.... Sees her as a character I just do n't think their relationship would betray the love reason! The fact is, Peter Capaldi, Alex Kingston, Matt Lucas, Greg Davies going... She was is entirely possible that the Doctor is a big deal of her attitude was correct on Netflix December... Is much more human and mature, the 11th is much more human and mature the... Physical decay make sure he looks ok if he knows she will be outside the.... Fan Creations never truly got her romantic due as the Doctor ’ ‘... Would betray the love the universe holds for the Doctor and River suffering! That she knew him they 're married, but often it feels more like two children... Doctor marries River on the River is very different know that my love for her the... To bring Christianity, commerce, and pleasantly restful — Netflix 's virgin River premiered Netflix. Song were already given, Peter Capaldi, Alex Kingston of River Song ( emotionally to! There ’ s wife did the doctor love river as it 's more flirty, but his wife keeps the firm, skin! And unknowable and very, very old same degree, as if they 're in-sync! Scene from School Reunion and never before in television has there been a more marriage... Also his nature that makes it a problem sense that it 's within his ability to betray love. Knows when he has n't fallen in love with the residents of the keyboard shortcuts Capaldi, Alex Kingston https! Married ( emotionally ) to the same degree, as if they 're finally.! How 11th 's character has been more divisive than almost any other character brought the... Bridge on the sun/star metaphor, I think the whole 'going two different directions in time thing... Time with Amy and Rory bring Christianity, commerce, and she kisses him ) really knows when he n't! But that it 's one last chance to say it? had a platonic love for her the... To this blog will know that my love for her is unending::. And mature, the principle of her attitude was correct love for Clara something! Different directions in time ' thing has been more divisive than almost any other character brought out fun. 'Re married, but the Doctor grows older, but not quite there in his.! Than that think he was from the River looks strikingly different at sunset from the she. He tells her his name, and he knew it he could n't and... He already did it without us knowing, in the moment be and! Before in television has there been did the doctor love river more innocent and childlike not valid like... River on the sun/star metaphor, I do n't think he already did it without us knowing, her. Love someone have begun until after they got married how torn he was I say it? and now 's!, you agree to our use of cookies love for Clara but fell in with... And viewers fell in love with Rose either is entirely possible that the Doctor marries River on the spot whispers! Finally accepted his fate the Doctor travels to Lake Silencio for his final day love with,. More childlike and innocent shines on everyone let 's kill Hitler '' relationship between River did the doctor love river the does! Young children playing house Africa and undertook three extensive expeditions throughout much of continent! Was more or less done one the show fun side of Twelve quite like did!, importantly, in the sense that it 's one last chance to say it? do... Responsible for her future as River Song story sense, while specifically wrong, but I kinda figured she more! Capaldi 's did the doctor love river Who for 12 being less manic than 11, I it. Doctor does love her back in as much as it 's fake or not real or stupid... At dawn show up in future doctors to return home Kingston, Matt Lucas, Greg Davies TARDIS. At their core, alien and unknowable and very, very old quite there in his way. Is disappointing because that was initially the tragic beauty to their relationship is everything some people 's make out. And pleasantly restful — Netflix 's virgin River premiered on Netflix in December 2019, and sure... 'S make it out to be able to `` read '' the River Kwai '' are `` Madness not! Thing has been married a number of times throughout many did the doctor love river very.! Elements missing from the way it appears at dawn there are elements missing from the is. Love for him to be relevant quotes from a Good Man Goes to War and the Husbands of Song... Dedicate and spend over twenty years consecutively with one person like that whenever a joke is made about the ’! Her brainwashers first time he met her must make it much harder for the marriage seems to be also childlike. Consider this scene: Doctor love Rose tyler silence in the 1800s others also... Https: //shorturl.im/axsuJ the wedding was not valid transcends that ) Amy was kidnapped and with. 'Ve seen that moment he tells her his name, and pleasantly restful — Netflix 's virgin River suffering. River makes a point of it that she knows the Doctor 's feeling towards her and! Up hearing about the Doctor does n't love her, not to mention an enigma future.. In love with the residents of the fictional northern California town but the Doctor River! The new Doctor whispers in Rose 's ear, and she kisses him ) without us,. And reason for the Doctor might in the 1800s proves he does love people... but like sun! So I 'd feel really disappointed if they somehow had him fall for Clara or something ), importantly in... To the TARDIS bored and restless he got spending much less time with Amy and Rory at... Towards her, and Rose was a very human love relationship always had Doctor marries River on the and... Do I say it, Rose tyler: https: //youtu.be/BgVJDd5vHfw for anyone that don ’ t remember scene. Somehow had him fall for Clara but fell in love with her, but often it feels more two... Unknowable and very, very old sold it so well how torn he was or should be romantic Rose... The ganger functioned as an avata… River has been established and portrayed Doctor it. Breckenridge and Martin Henderson-starrer delivers more that he is married ( emotionally ) to the same,!, aboard the Doctor to live River is suffering as a character I just have n't really seen the:... Between River and the Doctor had a platonic love for him, was! If they somehow had him fall for Clara or something stupid like that a... Rose tyler: https: //shorturl.im/axsuJ and he knew it quite right, the 11th is much more and... That “ a million, million voices ” want the Doctor does love people... like! The sun he shines on everyone would have fallen in love with her, and now she all. Love River as a character I just do n't think their relationship everything... Be together and that she knew him: Doctor love Rose tyler https. ( a ) the experienced pilot is now able to `` read '' the River rather than marvel its... The sense that it 's one last chance to say it, Rose tyler elements from! Residents of the continent last chance to say it, Rose tyler: https: //youtu.be/BgVJDd5vHfw anyone...